Catherine the Great: A tale of political ambition, forbidden love, and scandalous decisions

Catherine the Great's palace
Source: https://pixabay.com/photos/catherine-s-palace-russia-5912762/

Catherine the Great, Empress of Russia, remains an enigmatic and captivating figure, whose 34-year reign transformed a vast empire and forever changed Russian history.

 

A German princess who ascended to the Russian throne through a coup, a visionary reformer who grappled with the realities of absolute power, and a patron of the arts who engaged with the leading intellectuals of her time, Catherine's story is full of ambition, intrigue, triumph, and contradiction.

 

How did a foreign-born princess become one of Russia's most influential rulers?

 

What drove her ambitious reforms?

 

And what were the personal relationships that shaped her rule?

Her privileged childhood

Born on May 2, 1729, in Stettin, Prussia, (modern Szczecin in Poland) as Sophia Augusta Fredericka, she was the daughter of Prince Christian August of Anhalt-Zerbst and Princess Johanna Elisabeth of Holstein-Gottorp.

 

Her family, though noble, was not particularly wealthy or influential, and her early years were spent in a relatively modest and disciplined environment.

 

Sophia's education was typical of the nobility of her time, focusing on languages, literature, and religion.

 

However, her intelligence, curiosity, and ambition set her apart from an early age. Her governess described her as a bright and determined child, qualities that would serve her well in the years to come.

 

Her relationship with her mother was complex and often strained, reflecting the tensions and expectations of her noble upbringing.

The turning point in Sophia's life came with her introduction to the Russian court. Her mother's ambition and connections led to an opportunity for Sophia to marry the Grand Duke Peter, the heir to the Russian throne.

 

The prospect of such a marriage was both an opportunity and a challenge, requiring Sophia to leave her homeland and adapt to a new culture, language, and religion. 


Her marriage into the Russian royal family

Her marriage to Peter III, the heir to the Russian throne, brought her into a world of intrigue and power, far removed from her modest upbringing in Stettin, Prussia.

 

Though initially perceived as a foreigner with little influence, her intelligence, ambition, and adaptability soon set her apart.

 

The early years of her marriage were fraught with challenges, as she navigated the complexities of the Russian court and the erratic behavior of her husband.

 

Her conversion to Orthodox Christianity, dedication to learning the Russian language,  and her adoption of the name Catherine endeared her to the Russian people, laying the groundwork for her future rule.

 

Catherine's keen interest in Enlightenment philosophy also began to shape her vision for governance, fostering a desire to bring progressive reforms to a nation steeped in tradition.

Catherine's early years in Russia were marked by challenges and disappointments.

 

Her marriage to Peter was troubled from the start, characterized by incompatibility and mutual disdain. 


How Catherine seized power from her husband

Peter's rule, though brief, was marked by unpopular decisions and erratic behavior that alienated key segments of the Russian elite and military.

 

His admiration for Frederick the Great of Prussia, Russia's enemy at the time, and his sudden withdrawal from the Seven Years' War, angered the military establishment.

 

Meanwhile, his attempts to modernize the army and his treatment of the Orthodox Church created further discontent.

 

Catherine, aware of the growing dissatisfaction with her husband's rule, began to cultivate alliances with key figures within the Russian court and military.

 

Her romantic relationship with Grigory Orlov, a charismatic and influential officer, proved instrumental in securing support for the impending coup.

 

The discontent with Peter's policies, coupled with Catherine's strategic alliances, created a volatile political climate ripe for upheaval.

The coup itself unfolded with remarkable speed and precision. On the morning of June 28, 1762, Catherine donned a soldier's uniform and rode to the Winter Palace in St. Petersburg, where she was proclaimed Empress by the troops.

 

The symbolic act of donning military attire and her public appearance with the soldiers not only demonstrated her resolve but also solidified her support within the army.

 

Peter, caught off guard and isolated, had little choice but to abdicate.

Peter's abdication and subsequent arrest were followed by his mysterious death just a week later, a matter that has remained the subject of speculation and debate.

 

While Catherine's involvement in his death has never been conclusively proven, the shadow of suspicion added a layer of intrigue to an already dramatic ascent to power.


Was Catherine a good ruler?

Catherine the Great's ascension to the throne marked the beginning of a period of intense reform and modernization that would fundamentally reshape Russian governance and society.

 

Her reign was characterized by a commitment to enlightened absolutism, a governing philosophy that sought to combine absolute monarchical power with progressive reforms inspired by Enlightenment ideals.

 

Catherine's vision for Russia was ambitious, aiming to transform a largely feudal society into a modern and enlightened state.

 

One of the earliest and most significant attempts at reform came with the convocation of the Legislative Commission in 1767.

 

Comprising representatives from various social classes, the commission was tasked with drafting a new legal code.

 

Catherine's "Nakaz," or Instruction, guided the commission's work, reflecting her desire to create a more rational and humane legal system.

 

Though the commission ultimately failed to produce a new code, the Nakaz itself became a symbol of Catherine's reformist intentions and her alignment with Enlightenment principles.

Catherine's reforms extended beyond the legal sphere, touching various aspects of Russian society.

 

The Charter to the Nobility granted new privileges and rights to the nobility, strengthening their position within the social hierarchy.

 

Simultaneously, the Charter of the Towns sought to improve urban administration and governance.

 

These reforms, while progressive in intent, often reinforced existing social divisions, reflecting the complexities and contradictions of Catherine's rule.

 

For example, they further codified the servitude of the serfs, effectively tying them more closely to the land and their noble masters.

The question of serfdom loomed large during Catherine's reign, embodying the tensions between progressive ideals and the realities of Russian society.

 

While Catherine expressed sympathy for the plight of the serfs and considered various measures to alleviate their condition, she was also mindful of the nobility's interests and the potential for unrest.

 

The delicate balance between reform and stability led to incremental changes rather than sweeping emancipation, a compromise that underscored the challenges of governance in a diverse and stratified society.


Catherine's military campaigns and expansion

Catherine the Great's reign was marked not only by domestic reform but also by a series of ambitious military campaigns and strategic foreign policy decisions that expanded Russia's influence and territory.

 

Her approach to military and foreign affairs was characterized by a combination of pragmatism, ambition, and a keen understanding of the geopolitical landscape of 18th-century Europe.

 

One of the defining aspects of Catherine's foreign policy was her engagement with the Ottoman Empire.

 

The Russo-Turkish Wars, a series of conflicts spanning several decades, were driven by Russia's desire to secure access to the Black Sea and expand its influence in the Balkans.

 

Catherine's military successes in these wars, particularly the Treaty of Küçük Kaynarca in 1774, marked a significant shift in the balance of power in the region, granting Russia important territorial gains and a foothold in the strategically vital Crimea.

Catherine's foreign policy also extended to Central and Western Europe, most notably in her involvement in the partitioning of Poland.

 

The partitions, conducted in collaboration with Austria and Prussia, resulted in the dismemberment of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth and the absorption of significant Polish territories into the Russian Empire.

 

While these actions were viewed by many contemporaries as a betrayal of Enlightenment principles, they reflected Catherine's realpolitik approach and her determination to secure Russia's western borders.

 

The annexation of Crimea in 1783 further solidified Russia's position in the Black Sea region and demonstrated Catherine's willingness to capitalize on opportunities to expand Russian territory.

 

The annexation, while celebrated in Russia, created tensions with the Ottoman Empire and other European powers, underscoring the complexities and risks of Catherine's expansionist policies.

Catherine's military campaigns were not solely focused on territorial expansion; they also reflected her desire to modernize and strengthen the Russian military.

 

Her investments in the navy, the reorganization of the army, and the establishment of military schools were part of a broader effort to transform Russia into a modern military power capable of competing with the leading European states.

 

Catherine's approach to foreign policy was also marked by a network of alliances and diplomatic engagements.

 

Her correspondence with European rulers and intellectuals, her alliances with powers such as Austria and Prussia, and her ability to navigate the shifting alliances of 18th-century Europe were testament to her diplomatic acumen and her understanding of the intricacies of international politics.


Catherine's scandalous personal relationships

Catherine's marriage to Peter III was troubled from the start, marked by incompatibility and mutual disdain.

 

While the marriage provided her with the opportunity to ascend to the Russian throne, it was also a source of personal frustration and disappointment.

 

Her ability to navigate the challenges of her marriage and position herself for power revealed a woman of remarkable resilience and ambition.

 

One of the most significant relationships in Catherine's life was with Grigory Potemkin, a statesman, military leader, and her lover.

 

Potemkin's influence extended beyond the personal realm, as he became one of Catherine's most trusted advisors and collaborators.

 

Their relationship, both passionate and intellectual, played a crucial role in shaping key policies and military campaigns.

 

Even after their romantic relationship ended, Potemkin remained a central figure in Catherine's rule, reflecting a partnership that transcended conventional boundaries.

Catherine's relationships with other men, including Grigory Orlov, who played a key role in the coup against Peter III, were also instrumental in her political life.

 

These relationships were often characterized by a blend of romance, friendship, and political alliance, reflecting Catherine's ability to forge connections that served both her personal and political needs.

 

Catherine's correspondence with leading intellectuals of her time, such as Voltaire, provided her with a platform to engage with Enlightenment ideas and connect with the broader intellectual currents of 18th-century Europe.

 

Her letters reveal a woman of keen intellect and curiosity, committed to the ideals of the Enlightenment, even as she grappled with the practicalities of governance.

Finally, Catherine's relationship with her son and successor, Paul I, was fraught with tension and misunderstanding.

 

She even considered removing him from the line of succession, favoring her grandson Alexander instead.

 

Her decision to sideline Paul and keep him away from power created a rift that never fully healed, reflecting the complexities of succession and the challenges of motherhood in the context of absolute power.


Her death and legacy

Her rule, which lasted for 34 years, concluded with her death on November 17, 1796.

 

On the morning of that day, Catherine suffered a stroke and fell into a coma. Despite the efforts of her physicians, she never regained consciousness and passed away later that evening.

 

Her sudden death marked the end of an era and the close of one of the most transformative reigns in Russian history.

Catherine's son, Paul I, succeeded her to the throne. His relationship with his mother had been strained, and his rule marked a departure from many of Catherine's policies and approaches.

 

Paul's ascension brought about a shift in governance and a reevaluation of some of the reforms and initiatives that had characterized Catherine's rule.

 

Catherine's death and the transition of power were emblematic of the complexities and contradictions of her reign.

 

Her legacy continued to resonate, both in the immediate aftermath of her death and in the centuries that followed.

 

Her impact on Russian law, culture, military expansion, and governance left an indelible mark on the nation and on the broader European stage.