In Australian history classrooms, assessment has been mainly assessed through essays and exams. These formats still offer valuable insights into student learning but a growing body of educators and curriculum specialists have seen the need to use different assessment methods.
During the last two decades, curriculum guidelines have encouraged teachers to broaden assessment methods. They outline the need for students to evaluate sources and build historical arguments that communicate interpretation in a variety of forms.
That instruction has prompted teachers to explore assessments that focus on analysis skills and understanding of history as well as extended written responses.
The strengths, and weaknesses, of traditional essays
Traditional essays and exams have long been foundations of assessment in history classes, which carry a unique set of strengths.
They serve as effective tools for evaluating a student's knowledge and understanding of specific historical events and figures spanning multiple time periods.
Moreover, essays are particularly skilled at evaluating writing skills. They require students to develop an argument, organise thoughts logically, and use evidence to support conclusions, which improves their writing abilities.
In addition to assessing knowledge and writing prowess, essays and exams can also test a student's ability to think critically.
They require students to analyse historical events and make sense of primary and secondary sources, which encourages them to think critically and to formulate arguments.
Moreover, they provide a level of consistency, which provides a measure that can be used to compare student performance across the board.
This also makes grading easier for teachers.
However, like any educational approach, traditional essays and exams also come with built-in weaknesses.
Their main drawback is that they can often encourage a narrow focus on the memorisation of dates and names alongside relevant events.
This rote learning approach tends to detract from the broader understanding of historical trends within broader contexts.
Furthermore, traditional essays and exams often fail to foster creativity. They provide limited opportunities for students to explore alternative ways of demonstrating their understanding or expressing their knowledge innovatively.
High-stakes exams, in particular, can lead to heightened stress and anxiety among students.
This pressure can negatively impact their performance and hinder their overall learning experience.
Another key concern is that these traditional methods primarily assess writing and memorization skills.
Other vital skills, such as collaboration, presentation, research and multimedia skills, might be overlooked in the process.
Lastly, these traditional assessment methods typically offer a single point of assessment, thereby failing to capture a student's understanding or progress as a whole over time.
In education, the key is to implement a variety of assessment techniques which capture different aspects of learning and cater to different learning styles.
Such differentiation in assessment can aid in creating a more engaging and effective learning environment.
Other ideas for History assessment tasks
Role-Playing/Simulations
One effective strategy is to assign historical roleplays or simulations. Students might take on the personas of historical figures during a re-enactment of a parliamentary debate, treaty negotiation, or revolutionary assembly.
This method demands reading sources closely to argue from a historically accurate perspective and to respond effectively within a given historical framework.
For example, a class that studies the French Revolution could hold a National Assembly debate, with students who represent different estates and revolutionary factions.
In Australian contexts, simulations might include a debate on the 1967 Referendum or the Eureka Stockade trials.
When students prepare their speeches and anticipate opposition, they must apply research skills and critical reasoning in a historically grounded way.
Video creation
Another option is the creation of historical documentaries or video essays. With widely available digital tools such as WeVideo, iMovie, and Adobe Spark, students can plan, script, and edit presentations on key events, movements, or individuals.
This format requires the integration of visual sources and historical commentary into a clear timeline.
A task on the Vietnam War, for instance, might ask students to explore Australian media coverage from the 1960s and 1970s, evaluate how public perception shifted, and explain how that influenced government policy.
When students narrate over old footage and interviews, they use original historical sources while building a clear historical argument for a modern audience.
Competitions such as the National History Challenge have showcased excellent student-produced documentaries that reflect deep historical understanding.
Multimedia Presentations
In addition to performance-based and multimedia tasks, physical or digital exhibitions can encourage students to design planned exhibitions around specific historical themes.
A class that studies Ancient Egypt might develop an exhibition on burial customs, where each student contributes an thematic panel that combines an artefact label and its source explanation.
Students must research their object’s historical context, explain its relevance, and connect it to wider cultural or religious beliefs.
Some schools have extended this practice to local community partnerships, such as when they work with museums during History Week or when they contribute to ANZAC commemorative displays.
This task assesses content knowledge, source analysis, and written communication, while giving students control over their exhibition display.
Timeline Projects
By constructing detailed timelines, students develop an understanding of causal relationships and recognition of societal transformations.
They can also evaluate the importance of individual events. A Cold War unit might include a timeline that links global events to Australian domestic politics and that asks students to select events, justify their inclusion and add notes on why they matter.
Free digital platforms like Sutori and Timeline JS allow students to create interactive timelines with embedded media.
These tasks prompt students to decide which information is most important and explain historical trends in structured and visual formats.
Source Analysis Tasks
Students receive a selection of primary and secondary sources and are asked to answer a specific inquiry question.
For example, a unit on the Gallipoli campaign could include soldiers' letters, maps, official reports, and photographs.
The Australian War Memorial provides inquiry kits designed for classroom use.
Students must judge the reliability of the sources, identify viewpoints, and use the proof to draw a supported conclusion.
This approach directly matches the skills in senior history syllabuses and readies students for higher-level historical writing without requiring a full essay.
Podcasts
Some teachers have used podcast or radio show assignments, where students script and record short programs about a particular historical moment.
A program on the fall of the Berlin Wall might include interviews, news reports, and analysis sections.
Students must research their content carefully and structure their program in a way that keeps an audience informed and engaged.
Platforms such as Audacity and GarageBand allow students to edit and improve their recordings, while programs like ABC's "Days Like These" or UTS's "History Lab" are good example programmes.
The format supports clear organisation, logical order, and the use of historical terms.
Poster Presentations
Poster or infographic assignments can also be valuable for younger year levels.
They encourage concise summaries of historical content, the visual presentation of proof, and thematic clarity.
A poster on industrial-era reforms in Britain might include short biographies, legislative milestones, and visual data like factory inspection reports.
Online tools like Piktochart or Canva Education allow students to blend text and graphics effectively.
Students practise the skill of distilling detailed information into key points and of selecting the most relevant material for public communication.
What other things have you tried?
When teachers use a range of assessment types, they can judge student learning in a more genuine and interesting way.
These alternatives strengthen students' grasp of historical skills and content by giving them opportunities to apply their knowledge in different contexts and maintain the role of essays and exams.
Each task must be clearly scaffolded, aligned with curriculum objectives, and accompanied by specific success criteria.
When applied thoughtfully, these assessments can increase student confidence and enhance students' understanding of history.
Write a comment